top of page
Your Matchmaker
Meet Caroline
Hi, I'm Caroline Fenno—Founder of Moonstruck Matchmaking.
Long before I ever called myself a matchmaker, I was the person quietly paying attention… noticing who would naturally fit, who shared values, chemistry, and the kind of connection that actually lasts.
I started making introductions simply because I could see what others couldn’t.
One night, I was out with my best friend who was too shy to approach a man she had noticed across the bar. So I walked over, introduced myself, and brought him back to meet her. They were married within a couple of years—and that marriage lasted decades.
Another time, a girlfriend had just gone through a difficult breakup. I had met someone who I felt would be a great match for her, and I introduced them. They began dating, got married, and built a life together that has also lasted for decades.
Those moments stayed with me—not just because they worked, but because they reinforced something I’ve always believed: the right introduction, at the right time, can change everything.
That instinct eventually became something bigger.
I went on to build a successful matchmaking company in the Midwest, where I was personally responsible for hundreds of introductions and at least 14 marriages that I know of today.
With a background in business and technology and a B.S. in Management Information Systems, I bring both intuition and thoughtful strategy to the matchmaking process—creating introductions that are personal, intentional, and highly compatible.
After moving to Florida, I started hearing the same story over and over again: smart, successful people feeling frustrated with dating apps… tired of investing time, energy, and money into connections that went nowhere.
That’s why I created Moonstruck Matchmaking.
If you’re ready to stop swiping left and start dating right, you’re exactly who I created this for.
The Story Behind Moonstruck
Moonstruck Matchmaking was shaped by a simple realization:
Even in a room full of great people, not everyone meets the right person.
After hosting a wine tasting for 200 singles, I saw firsthand how easy it is to connect—and how rare it is to connect meaningfully. That experience made one thing clear: chemistry alone isn’t enough.
Timing, values, lifestyle, and emotional readiness all matter just as much. That’s where matchmaking changes everything.
Moonstruck was created as a more intentional alternative to modern dating—one that replaces endless searching with thoughtful, personalized introductions.
Every match is guided by real conversation, careful consideration, and an instinct that comes from years of experience—not algorithms or guesswork.
Because finding the right relationship shouldn’t feel random. It should feel aligned.
BY THE NUMBERS
A Track Record of Trust
14
MARRIAGES
10+
Years Experience
100s
Clients Served
100%
Personal Attention
Caroline didn't just find me a match—she found me my person. Her warmth, patience, and genuine care made all the difference. I never imagined this kind of happiness was possible at this stage of life.
— A MOONSTRUCK CLIENT
bottom of page